DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! newcritics is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

newcritics

the best in web criticism
Jump to original thread »
Author

Bah, Humbug and All That

Started by tomwatson · 11 months ago

If he wrote “A Christmas Carol” today, Charles Dickens might take flak for insidiously promoting a welfare state that could lead to higher taxes and SCHIP programs for the likes of Tiny Tim.But after more than a century and a half, Scrooge and his ghosts will be all over ... Continue reading »

5 comments

  • My vote for the best portrayal of Scrooge (though perhaps not the finest production) goes to George C. Scott.

    More here.

    Or just watch some of it
    here.
  • I am partial to the Mr. Magoo version, starring Jim Backus.

    We just watched the 80s George C. Scott version and it's very faithful to the text, perhaps the most so.
  • We'll be watching that one tonight. I love it.
  • Someday, when the technology can make it seamless, I'd like to see a version made up of the best of all of them...

    Alistair Sim as Scrooge with the Cratchitts from the Albert Finney version and Edward Woodward as the Ghost of Christmas Present from the George C. Scott version and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come from that one too---I like the way his bones creak and Alec Guinness as Marley's Ghost.

    And from the Magoo version, the razzleberry dressing.

    I hope you all have the Lord's bright blessing, and knowing we're together, knowing we're together heart and hand, and you have the whitest Christmas, the lightest, brightest Christmas, a Christmas far more glorious than grand!
  • I really am partial to the Mr Magoo version.

    But I saw the Patrick Stewart one-man show on Broadway back in the mid-'90s. What a tour-de-force! And it addressed exactly the point you make in your first paragraph. He was doing it right around the time of Gingrich's Contract with America, and when he got to the line, "Are there no workhouses?" he got just a huge reaction from the audience. It really IS a subversive text for a modern consumer corporate Christmas.
Please login to comment.
Returning? Login